Today’s deadly Japan earthquake could be related to the 1995 Kobe earthquake

By David Jacobson, M.Sc. and Ross Stein, Ph.D., Temblor

Check your hazard rank

Today’s M=5.9 earthquake in Japan struck just north of the city of Osaka, which is home to 2.7 million people.

 

At 7:58 a.m. local time, a M=5.9 earthquake struck Osaka, Japan, leaving 3 people, dead, and hundreds injured. The quake resulted in numerous collapsed walls, broken water pipes, and left 170,000 homes without power. Since the mainshock, over 100 aftershocks have continued to rattle the city, which is home to approximately 2.7 million people.

Today’s M=5.9 earthquake just north of Japan resulted in three fatalities, hundreds of injuries and significant damage throughout the city. This photo shows the collapsed gate at the Myotoku-ji temple. (Photo from: SF Gate)

 

Near but not on a major fault

Based on the earthquake’s location, today’s quake struck just off the Takatsuki Fault, a right-lateral strike-slip fault in the northern part of Osaka. This fault last ruptured in 1596, and typically ruptures every 2,600 years in M≈6.8 events. Therefore, this fault is susceptible to rupturing in large events, which could be devastating to Osaka.

This Temblor map shows the location of today’s earthquake just north of the city of Osaka, Japan. This earthquake struck just off the Takatsuki Fault, which has a rough recurrence interval of 2,600 years.

 

Very Strong Shaking

Despite this quake’s moderate magnitude, it produced significant ground shaking, which resulted in the few fatalities and obvious damage. Based on the nearest seismic station, shaking levels reached 0.8 g, 6 km from the epicenter. This translates to violent shaking and potential heavy damage. Such levels of ground shaking are typically not seen in earthquakes of this magnitude. However, in April, a M=5.6 earthquake in western Japan also registered high (0.5-0.7 g) shaking typically associated with much larger quakes. This illustrates that Japan’s dense network of sensors capture high levels of ground shaking even for small quakes, raising the possibility that such strong shaking in small shocks is far more common worldwide than we now realize.

This map shows ground accelerations recorded from today’s M=5.9 earthquake just outside of Osaka. (Data and map from the National Research Institute for Earthquake Science and Disaster Resilience (NIED))

 

This map shows a comparison of the network of earthquake sensors in California and Japan. (Figure from: Shakealert.org)

 

Ghost of the 1995 Kobe shock?

Today’s earthquake may also have been promoted by another famous, and devastating Japanese earthquake, the M=6.9 Kobe earthquake in 1995. Toda et al (1998) calculated a broad stress increase on the strike-slip faults of the corridor between Kobe and Kyoto known as the ‘Kinki District.’ (left panel below). This was accompanied by a sudden 10-fold increase in the rate of small (M≥2.6) earthquakes in the District. They also calculated stresses on the major active faults (right panel above). In the Toda et al (1998) abstract, they wrote, “We estimate that a calculated 3-bar stress increase on the eastern section of the Arima-Takatsuki Tectonic Line near Kyoto causes a fivefold increase in the 30-year probability of subsequent large earthquakes near Kyoto.” While the M=5.9 earthquake did not strike on the Takatsuki Fault itself, it does locate in the region that was stressed by the 1995 shock, and so larger quakes are also possible.

 

Based on the Global Earthquake Activity Rate (GEAR) model, today’s earthquake should not be a surprise. This model uses global strain rates and the last 40 years of seismicity to forecast the likely earthquake magnitude in your lifetime anywhere on earth. The figure below shows that at the site of today’s earthquake, a M=6.8 is likely. Therefore, today’s earthquake should be a wakeup call to a region susceptible to even larger quakes.

This Temblor map shows the Global Earthquake Activity Rate (GEAR) model for much of Japan. This map shows that in the location of today’s M=5.9 earthquake, a M=6.75+ is likely to occur in your lifetime.

 

References

Japan Meteorological Agency

Geofon Potsdam

Active Fault Database of Japan (AIST)

National Research Institute for Earthquake Science and Disaster Resilience (NIED)

Toda, S., R. S. Stein, P. A. Reasenberg, J. H. Dieterich, and A. Yoshida (1998), Stress transferred by the 1995 Mw = 6.9 Kobe, Japan, shock: Effect on aftershocks and future earthquake probabilities, J. Geophys. Res., 103, 24,543– 24,565, doi.org/10.1029/98JB00765

  • Gary Hind

    It’s also worth baring in mind that on April 12th 2013 a M5.8 magnitude earthquake took place on Awaji island, that shock took place on the southern end of the aftershock zone of the 1995 quake, the largest aftershocks from the 1995 quake were of M4.9 & 5.1 magnitude, typically the largest aftershock from a M6.9 event would be around M5.9, given the 1995 ‘bilateral’ fault rupture nature, the 2013 & 2018 quakes do kinda of serve as a final puzzle piece to the 1995 stress transfer wonderings!